Catholic Women and Contraception – 33% think the Church says “yes” to contraception

Before I changed course to enter the ministry, I planned to attend grad school for theoretical psychometrics.  I had, and still find tests measuring things about humans of interest. For example, the various preelection polls are almost always skewed cleverly in a direction. This irritates me, no matter which way skewed, since it is not good science.

When I first read the survey below, I was struck with the integrity of the questions and the handling of the results.  It was actually an accurate sample, and all the responses were reported.  Only then were possible interpretations offered. It was an honest survey of an important set of human behavior. Nowadays this is rare.  The old saw ” you can make statistics say anything you want” seems to infect the poll reporting and surveys offered today.

So, enjoy a responsible reporting of the feelings of Roman Catholic women on several important attitudes and actions.

Fr. Orthohippo

Published Friday, September 7, 2012 A.D. | By Stacy Trasancos

After a good long tirade around the kitchen last night during Caroline Kennedy’s “as a Catholic woman” speech, I tried to think of what will come next in the following weeks and months. There’s a report I’ve been promoting this week, and the timing is undoubtedly providential.

One thing I’ve noticed about controversy: It’s a process by which things can change. People are listening now, it’s our turn to take the stage.

Mary Rice Hasson, J.D., a woman I am proud to call a friend, is a Fellow in the Catholic Studies Program at the Ethics and Public Policy Center, Washington D.C. She is also the director of the Women, Faith, and Culture project together with Michele M. Hill who has been active in apostolates within the Archdiocese of Baltimore. These ladies have issued a preliminary report, What Catholic Women Think About Faith, Conscience, and Contraception, in which 824 Church-going Catholic women ages 18-54 were surveyed. (*Be sure to note how that is defined in the report.)

While the data indicates that most Catholic women do not fully support the Church’s teachings on contraception, the results also do not show the sweeping rejection of Church teaching the media portrays either. The picture is more nuanced. From the website, Women, Faith and Culture: Exploring What Catholic Women Think:

Catholic Women and Faith
90% say faith is important to daily life
72% rely on homilies to learn the faith
28% have gone to Confession within the year

Catholic Women and Contraception
33% think the Church says “yes” to contraception
13% say “yes” to Church teaching
37% say “no” to Church teaching
44% say “no, but maybe …” to Church teaching

The report shows that about one-third of Church-going Catholic women incorrectly believe that couples have the right to decide for themselves the moral acceptability of contraception – regardless of Church teaching. When Church teaching was explained, 44% were receptive to learning more. These results suggest the problem is in part catechetical, and that women want more instruction.

Church-going Catholic women fall into three groups, the researchers found: 1) “the faithful” who say “yes” to Church teaching, 2) “the dissenters” who say “no” to it, and 3) the “soft middle” who are reluctant, but receptive to more information.

The hope for this project is that good conversations can begin about how to reach the women who identify as Catholic but reject Church teaching on contraception, and yet, still in their heart want to do the right thing. Mary and Michele also hope that the data will inspire our priests to have confidence to preach the truth on this issue.

While 72% of women said that the homilies in Mass are their primary source for learning about Church teaching, more than eight in ten said they believe they can be “good Catholics” even if they “do not accept some of the Catholic Church’s teachings on sex, family planning, birth control, and reproduction.” They seem to be listening, but not accepting.

One last note: The honesty of this report is to be applauded. This is what scientific investigation is supposed be, a genuine search for truth to understand reality and seek solutions. Too often reports such as these are thrown at the public with broad appeals to authority and muddled analysis, so much so that it seems the study was conducted more to support a predetermined, politically expedient conclusion (i.e. breast-cancer and abortion, mental health and abortion, climate change, homosexual lifestyles, et caetera) than to actually investigate the truth. But how do you find real solutions if you don’t know the actual problem?

Although the conclusions in this report are rattling, they lay at our feet a description of a very real problem. Please read and share.

Full report here: What Catholic Women Think About Faith, Conscience, and Contraception

Website here: Women, Faith and Culture: Exploring What Catholic Women Think


About Fr. Orthohippo

The blog of a retired Anglican priest (MSJ), his musings, journey, humor, wonderment, and comments on today's scene.
This entry was posted in authority, catholic, christian education, media bias, Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s